丹佛华人资讯网
  • 首页
    • 电子黄页
    • 科州华商广告
    • 新增商家申请表 >
      • 商家推荐表
    • 餐馆,甜品店,面包店
    • 食品公司,餐馆服务
    • 超级市场,酒庄,参茸海味,药妆零食
    • 保险经纪
    • 人寿保险,退休理财
    • 地产经纪, 银行,贷款公司
    • 快递,汇款,招牌,印刷,电脑
    • 西医师,眼镜行,脊骨神经医生,牙医
    • 中医,中药房,中成药,按摩,足疗
    • 长者活动中心,成人护理
    • 家电,抽油烟机,冷暖气安装修理,电工,水管工,水泥工
    • 装修,庭院,杂工, 风水 >
      • 装修工程心得分享
      • 工程心得分享表
    • 律师
    • 会计师,税务师
    • 代办,摄影,翻译
    • 教会,佛堂
    • 社团服务,学校社团
    • 旅行社,机场接送,包车服务,短租
    • 理发师,美容院,裁缝师,洗衣店,宠物相关
    • 中文,音乐,舞蹈,绘画,体育,中医,武术学校
    • 车行,驾校,修车
    • 金铺,殡葬服务
  • 科州讯息
    • 活动讯息 >
      • 2023年科州贺岁活动总汇
      • 我与科州的邂逅 | 科罗拉多州摄影图文大赛 >
        • 一号参赛者:张恣宽(网名:长心宽) >
          • 作品集
        • 二号参赛者:宇文棠龙 Tanglong YuwenLink Page >
          • 作品集
        • 三号参赛者: 陈永锡 >
          • 作品集
        • 四号参赛者: Yudan Lou (娄羽丹)Link Page >
          • 作品集
        • 五号参赛者: Camelia Kong (孔献华) >
          • 作品集
        • 六号参赛者 Syla女士 >
          • 作品集
        • 七号参赛者 郭洪宇先生 >
          • 作品集
        • 八号参赛者 郭韬先生 >
          • 作品集
        • 九号参赛者 温摩西先生 >
          • 作品集
        • 十号参赛者 兔子女士 >
          • 作品集
    • 新冠头条 >
      • 新冠补助
      • 新冠疫苗
      • 新冠检测
    • 税务讯息
    • 美食图鉴
    • 美食考察 >
      • 2023年年菜总汇
      • 2022年年菜总汇
    • 私房食堂
    • 旅游指南
    • 科州何处去
    • 丹佛,我们的家
    • 我们的科州,我们的故事
    • 科州人走天下
    • 科州华人频道 >
      • 视频
      • 播客
  • 交流广场
    • 外卖菜单
    • 义工报名
    • 社区资源
    • 平价诊所
    • 家暴庇护服务
    • 语言学校 >
      • 丹佛 >
        • Emily Griffith学校
        • 春天学院
      • 南丹佛 >
        • 春天学院(在阿拉帕侯社区大学校区内)链接页面
      • 奥罗拉 >
        • 奥罗拉社区大学(不是密集课程)
      • 湖木 / 高登 >
        • 红石社区大学
      • 波德 >
        • 科罗拉多大学波德分校
      • 科泉 >
        • 科罗拉多大学科泉分校
        • 派克峰社区大学 (不是密集课程)
      • 科林斯堡 >
        • 前沿社区大学科林斯堡校区(不是密集课程)
      • Loveland
      • 前沿社区大学Loveland校区(不是密集课程)
  • 分类广告
    • 招聘求职
    • 分租出租
    • 汽车买卖
    • 生意转让
    • 二手物品
    • 提交讯息 (免费)
    • 电子版
  • 艺文专区
    • 作家 >
      • 游守义先生
      • 梁应权先生
      • 吴怀楚先生
      • 吴纪珍女士
      • 方诺女士
      • 罗环环女士
      • 简名佐女士
    • 书画家 >
      • 张昕先生
      • 张桐先生
      • 周杰卫先生
      • 苏彰诗先生 >
        • 画廊网址
      • 耿默女士
      • 悲痕先生
      • 依艺女士
      • 游陈瑶珍女士
      • 丁三宝先生
    • 摄影家 >
      • 叶娴女士
      • 余珂昕小姐
      • 张恣宽先生
      • 宇文棠龙先生
      • 陈永锡先生
      • 娄羽丹女士
      • 孔献华女士
      • Syla女士
      • 郭洪宇先生
      • 郭韬先生
      • 温摩西先生
      • 兔子女士
    • 手工艺术家 >
      • 李一冉小姐
      • 陶然小姐
    • 其它综合 >
      • 外州演唱会片段
      • 文房四宝网购
      • 资讯网读书会 >
        • 豆瓣书评
      • 读者投书

网站讯息

1/3/2016

 
Picture
去年十二月二十五日美国新闻和世界报道杂志有一则关于中国新闻自由的报导,文章里记者访问了上海外国语大学的学生,指出该校学生对于美国希望自由的渴望, 也呼应了美国主流媒体对中国新闻和言论自由的批评。该校新闻和传播学院院长郭可发稿该杂志表示学生对于作者对于他们采访内容收到负面解读讶异,也从一个中 国学者的立场,发表对新闻和言论自由的见解。以下是郭可教授发表文章的全文摘录。

Critique on the Welsh story at
http://www.usnews.com/…/journalism-is-gradually-changing-in…
Dear Editor,
I am writing to critique on the news article released on December 25, 2015 about “China jails more journalists than any other country, but media students say the landscape is changing” (hereinafter known as the Welsh story), written by Teresa Welsh who joined an informal session with our global journalism students in Shanghai on the afternoon on December 9, 2015 during her one-week visit to China.
After I shared the news link of the Welsh story among our participating journalism students, I was told that they had felt shocked when they compared the general impression drawn from the Welsh story with the actual dialogues that afternoon, which they considered candid, frank and honest.
Why were they shocked? Because the Welsh story has narrated an impression, particularly among readers who know nothing and little about China, that China is still a dictatorship communist China with no freedom of speech (at least not in line with the US standards), no matter what. While it may be true, according to Jim Wolf, a former Reuters correspondent who initiated the informal session and has been teaching English journalistic writing at Shanghai International Studies University, that the Welsh story has meant to genuinely report her China trip with no deliberate effort to negate China, participating journalism students feel that the Welsh story is not at all reporting the whole truth (a target as stated in the lead of the Welsh story) in a changing China, as it lacks Chinese contexts and backgrounding information, by having reported true facts in a simplistic manner, but still with misquotes as in the case for Jim Wolf who claimed that the Welsh story had misquoted him.
First, the Welsh story has employed a long-cherished typical US news frame to address an issue of self-censorship in China which has different definitions about freedom of speech and roles of journalism, that is, using an apple standard (the US) to measure and evaluate the taste and quality of an orange (China). Funny as it is, the U.S. itself has spent more than 200 years modifying and melding the journalistic practices and US-style press freedom into the US society in a stable, smooth and effective manner. China, though an ancient civilization with a history of 5000 years, did not really start its status quo of a modern nation-state until 1911 and is still in the process of perfecting its own China model of national development, including media management system. Therefore, by simply highlighting its jailing of journalists as the highest in the world, the Welsh story is not projecting a complete scenario (let alone truth) about press freedom in China, or at least too simplistic according to Karen Gill, a K-State journalism graduate who considers the teaching of English news writing in Shanghai no different from that in the U.S. after she taught for two months in Shanghai. What matters so much between the U.S. and China only ends up in the degree of different perceptions of press freedom and different national development stages.
Second, the Welsh story also lacks historical perspective and does not expound under what circumstances most Chinese people value the concept of press freedom. During the past two centuries, China has undergone social chaos and turmoil in a series of external and internal wars, which deprived all the Chinese people of a stable and better-off life. In addition, the collapse of the Soviet Union on December 25, 1991, that came as a result of pursuing freedom of speech and democracy, remains vivid and fresh in most Chinese minds as the Soviet collapse transported overnight the living standards of Soviet people back to 20 years ago. That is why my parents, as farmers in East China, who experienced chaotic and poor stages in their youth in China, treasure so much their current better-off and stable life and want to express their support for the local government in China because they now enjoy their pensions and medical services despite the fact that they used to be farmers. Obviously, the Welsh story fails to provide the Chinese context in which most Chinese individuals tend to place current better lives as their first priority after so many years of chaos and definitely freedom of speech, viewed as a universal value in China but with a potential for creating chaos as it was the case in the Soviet Union, should not go so far as to destroy a stable and peaceful environment for national development and better lives among common Chinese people.
Of course, I well understand that it may be a mission impossible for Teresa Welsh to include all the above backgrounding information in the story as she was just in China for one week. But CHEN Peiqin, a journalism professor in Shanghai who team taught with Jim Wolf and Karen Gill, suggested that the Welsh story might as well have explained the newsworthy real reasons for all the surprises that Teresa Welsh herself had experienced during her one-week visit to China and would be way more professional and objective if the Welsh story had quoted Karen Gill and explored why the teaching of English journalistic writing in China, so different in their perceptions of freedom of speech from the U.S., is not that different from that in the U.S..
That would have been a true reflection of our candid and frank discussions and interviews in our informal session on December 9, which our participating journalism students would feel more comfortable. But for now, to be frank, we feel that we were being taken advantage of or even cheated for the sake of this Welsh story.
(The writer Guo Ke is Dean of School of Journalism and Communication at Shanghai International Studies University, who moderated the informal session on December 9, 2015. He wanted to thank Jim Wolf for having initiated the informal session and Teresa Welsh for releasing the story as it has provided a good chance for all participating journalism students to illuminate a live case study on freedom of speech in China and the U.S., as a continued discussion of his class on Chinese media studies.)



Comments are closed.
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    图片
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    图片
    Picture
    Picture

    Archives

    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013

    RSS Feed

Picture
此网页所有版权为丹佛华人资讯网所有。 有对网页有关的问题请于info@denverchinesesource.com联络网页编辑
  • 首页
    • 电子黄页
    • 科州华商广告
    • 新增商家申请表 >
      • 商家推荐表
    • 餐馆,甜品店,面包店
    • 食品公司,餐馆服务
    • 超级市场,酒庄,参茸海味,药妆零食
    • 保险经纪
    • 人寿保险,退休理财
    • 地产经纪, 银行,贷款公司
    • 快递,汇款,招牌,印刷,电脑
    • 西医师,眼镜行,脊骨神经医生,牙医
    • 中医,中药房,中成药,按摩,足疗
    • 长者活动中心,成人护理
    • 家电,抽油烟机,冷暖气安装修理,电工,水管工,水泥工
    • 装修,庭院,杂工, 风水 >
      • 装修工程心得分享
      • 工程心得分享表
    • 律师
    • 会计师,税务师
    • 代办,摄影,翻译
    • 教会,佛堂
    • 社团服务,学校社团
    • 旅行社,机场接送,包车服务,短租
    • 理发师,美容院,裁缝师,洗衣店,宠物相关
    • 中文,音乐,舞蹈,绘画,体育,中医,武术学校
    • 车行,驾校,修车
    • 金铺,殡葬服务
  • 科州讯息
    • 活动讯息 >
      • 2023年科州贺岁活动总汇
      • 我与科州的邂逅 | 科罗拉多州摄影图文大赛 >
        • 一号参赛者:张恣宽(网名:长心宽) >
          • 作品集
        • 二号参赛者:宇文棠龙 Tanglong YuwenLink Page >
          • 作品集
        • 三号参赛者: 陈永锡 >
          • 作品集
        • 四号参赛者: Yudan Lou (娄羽丹)Link Page >
          • 作品集
        • 五号参赛者: Camelia Kong (孔献华) >
          • 作品集
        • 六号参赛者 Syla女士 >
          • 作品集
        • 七号参赛者 郭洪宇先生 >
          • 作品集
        • 八号参赛者 郭韬先生 >
          • 作品集
        • 九号参赛者 温摩西先生 >
          • 作品集
        • 十号参赛者 兔子女士 >
          • 作品集
    • 新冠头条 >
      • 新冠补助
      • 新冠疫苗
      • 新冠检测
    • 税务讯息
    • 美食图鉴
    • 美食考察 >
      • 2023年年菜总汇
      • 2022年年菜总汇
    • 私房食堂
    • 旅游指南
    • 科州何处去
    • 丹佛,我们的家
    • 我们的科州,我们的故事
    • 科州人走天下
    • 科州华人频道 >
      • 视频
      • 播客
  • 交流广场
    • 外卖菜单
    • 义工报名
    • 社区资源
    • 平价诊所
    • 家暴庇护服务
    • 语言学校 >
      • 丹佛 >
        • Emily Griffith学校
        • 春天学院
      • 南丹佛 >
        • 春天学院(在阿拉帕侯社区大学校区内)链接页面
      • 奥罗拉 >
        • 奥罗拉社区大学(不是密集课程)
      • 湖木 / 高登 >
        • 红石社区大学
      • 波德 >
        • 科罗拉多大学波德分校
      • 科泉 >
        • 科罗拉多大学科泉分校
        • 派克峰社区大学 (不是密集课程)
      • 科林斯堡 >
        • 前沿社区大学科林斯堡校区(不是密集课程)
      • Loveland
      • 前沿社区大学Loveland校区(不是密集课程)
  • 分类广告
    • 招聘求职
    • 分租出租
    • 汽车买卖
    • 生意转让
    • 二手物品
    • 提交讯息 (免费)
    • 电子版
  • 艺文专区
    • 作家 >
      • 游守义先生
      • 梁应权先生
      • 吴怀楚先生
      • 吴纪珍女士
      • 方诺女士
      • 罗环环女士
      • 简名佐女士
    • 书画家 >
      • 张昕先生
      • 张桐先生
      • 周杰卫先生
      • 苏彰诗先生 >
        • 画廊网址
      • 耿默女士
      • 悲痕先生
      • 依艺女士
      • 游陈瑶珍女士
      • 丁三宝先生
    • 摄影家 >
      • 叶娴女士
      • 余珂昕小姐
      • 张恣宽先生
      • 宇文棠龙先生
      • 陈永锡先生
      • 娄羽丹女士
      • 孔献华女士
      • Syla女士
      • 郭洪宇先生
      • 郭韬先生
      • 温摩西先生
      • 兔子女士
    • 手工艺术家 >
      • 李一冉小姐
      • 陶然小姐
    • 其它综合 >
      • 外州演唱会片段
      • 文房四宝网购
      • 资讯网读书会 >
        • 豆瓣书评
      • 读者投书